Obama to public: ACA not a tax increase; Obama in court: ACA's a tax increase

Now this is a great trick. Publicly, President Obama and his allies claimed, promised and assured the American people that the individual mandate contained in the Affordable Care Act wasn't a tax increase.

Anyone remember this?

Once the constitutionality of ACA was challenged, however, they immediately claimed the individual mandate was constitutional, because it is - voila! - a tax increase, not a penalty.

And ultimately, that's the tortured logic Chief Justice Roberts used to rewrite the law and rule Obamacare constitutional.

Ed Whelan makes a similar point over at Bench Memos:

The Obama administration got away with its bait-and-switch, first denying that the penalty for non-compliance with the mandate was a tax (and winning more favorable scoring from the Congressional Budget Office in the process), then salvaging the mandate-with-penalty on the ground that it could be reconceived as a tax. Any "tax," of course, is a tax on being uninsured - not, I would suspect, a tax that will suddenly win a lot of favor among the American people.
Just another example of how liberals will tell the American people one thing and then claim the exact opposite in court.

blog comments powered by Disqus